How Mr. C Stayed Out of the Black Lodge


One of Mr. C’s clear objectives during the new season is to stay out of the Black Lodge. He’s racing against time– his freedom outside the Waiting Room apparently has a 25-year limit on it. How does he manage to stay out of the Waiting Room?

The Facts


  • In Episode 2, The Arm tells Cooper that, “He must come back in before you can go out,” in reference to Cooper leaving the Waiting Room
  • In Episode 2, Mr. C Says that he’s supposed to return to the Black Lodge the next day. The mysterious voice on the phone also says he’s going to return to the Black Lodge
  • In Episode 2, Hawk travels out to Glastonbury Grove. On his way up, Margaret calls him, and he answers her that, “Once again, your log and I are on the same page.” When he gets to the Grove, the red curtains start flashing.
  •  In Episode 2, Mr. C gets a call from someone he initially thinks is Phillip Jeffries. This person says to Mr. C, “tomorrow you are going back to the Lodge”
  • In Episode 3, Mr. C starts getting sick at the same time Dougie-Tulpa’s having a heart attack
  • Dougie-Tulpa vomits, then apparates to the Waiting Room
  • When Mr. C is getting sick, he sees the Red Curtains flashing in front of him. He then sees Dougie-Tulpa sitting in the Waiting Room chair, and the red curtains fade. After this, he vomits.
  • The three detectives Fusco do a background check on Dougie, and find out he has no records before 1997.
  • In multiple episodes, Mr. C is shown compelling Diane-Tulpa to do things for him via text, culminating in…
  • During episode 16, Mr. C sends Diane-Tulpa the text, “:-) ALL,” causing her to attempt to murder the Blue Rose Task Force
  • Albert tells Tammy the story the original blue rose case, where a woman, while dying, says she is, “like the blue rose, ” and then disappears
  • In episodes 13 and 17, when Ray and Mr. C die, putting the ring on their bodies took them to the Waiting Room





What Does It All Mean?

He Must Come In Before You Can Go Out: Setting the Stage

Here are the stakes: When Mr. C first left the Waiting Room, apparently, there was a time limit set on how long he could be out in the world. Although we never get a reason why this is, it’s well understood by many of the stakeholders in the Twin Peaks Universe: Margaret and Hawk seem to understand that some kind of Waiting Room exchange was happening at this time, and Mr. C, Mike, and The Arm all understand that Mr. C is supposed to come in at that time so Coop can leave. Finally, even the mysterious voice that calls Mr. C knows that he’s supposed to return to the Lodge.


 Screen Shot 2017-11-11 at 10.07.40 PM

 Tulpa Control

Let’s talk about Mr. C and Tulpas. It’s clear that Mr. C, after creating a Tulpa, is able to exercise some degree of control over them. He makes Diane-Tulpa his informant, seemingly without her knowledge. With just a text, he forces Diane-Tulpa to attempt a murder of the entire Blue Rose Task Force, despite, as we learn from her emotional story, her clear hatred for Mr. C. By virtue of being her creator, Mr. C has powerful control over Diane-Tulpa’s actions.

Considering this development in Diane-Tulpa’s story, it makes sense that he would also have control of Dougie-Tulpa. This is discussed in further detail in Mr. C’s plan for the Blue Rose Task Force.




Dougie-Tulpa and the Decoy

Mr. C created Dougie for a number of reasons, but the Tulpa’s primary, most important mission: take Mr. C’s spot in the Lodge.

In 1997, Mr. C created Dougie-Tulpa. A few days before the switch occurred, Mr. C met with him again. He took Dougie’s wedding ring, and gave him the Lodge Ring.


The Switch

So, on the day of, Mr. C had everything in place. He needed to get Dougie to take his place, and needed to “trick” the Waiting Room into thinking the person who had just arrived was, in fact, the actual Doppelganger. To do this, he stacked the deck:

  • we saw from his and Ray’s deaths that wearing the ring takes your body to the Waiting Room: he put the ring on Dougie.
  • He knew when Tulpas die, they go to the Waiting Room: he engineered Dougie-Tulpa to have a heart attack during the Waiting Room switch.
  • Finally, knew the Waiting Room needed someone who looked like Coop, and who was made of the same stuff as Mr. C to switch with the real Cooper: he made Dougie-Tulpa out of the black bob orb material, and created a Tulpa of himself.


Screen Shot 2017-10-18 at 9.54.24 PM


Despite all this, he still wasn’t sure it would work. He mentions to Ray over dinner that, “The day after tomorrow I may need to be on my own for a while,” implying he still wasn’t sure if his plan would succeed.

Nonetheless, when they day came, it turned out to be enough: his plan succeeded, and he stayed out of the Waiting Room.

Building Off This Post

Nothing here yet, but

click here to return to the archive.


2 thoughts on “How Mr. C Stayed Out of the Black Lodge

  1. Some good logic except for calling the Black Lodge the “waiting room”. It has been clearly and definitively established in multiple official sources, including multiple places in the show, that the red room is the Black Lodge. It’s not up for debate or interpretation. This waiting room nonsense has been propagated by a small group of vocal fans and needs to stop, especially if you are claiming to be sticking to the facts of the show in your interpretations. It’s the Black Lodge. Officially. Definitely. End of story.


    1. Could you cite sources for that? I’m not pro-Waiting Room or anti-Black Lodge, and I haven’t really explored that question. However, calling it the Waiting Room in these posts accomplishes a number of things:

      – it’s unambiguous. When I’m talking about the Waiting Room, there’s no question about what location that is. This is also why I call the Mauve Tower the Mauve Tower, and the area within where the FIreman lives, “The Fireman’s Home.”

      – it minimizes the assumptions I’m making. Everyone makes some assumptions, including myself, but if I can eliminate the assumptions I’m making where I can, it allows my posts to sit closer to the facts of the show.

      – it’s apolitical. I’m not sure if it’s a part the Black Lodge or not (I lean toward it’s at least attached to the Lodge), but nobody can debate the Waiting Room is, actually, the Waiting Room.


Comments are closed.